View B · Team Scorecards
Who actually drafts well?
Hit rate, average AV, and class outcomes for every franchise, 2011–2025. Click a tile to see every pick.
Sort by
#1
DETLions
Hit %
21
Avg AV
10.4
Stars
24
Surplus $/yr
+4.3M
4-yr total
+1996M
n=116 · 2 super · 34 busts · 67% pos surplus
Best pick Penei Sewell · 2021 #7
#2
DALCowboys
Hit %
17
Avg AV
12.1
Stars
21
Surplus $/yr
+4.7M
4-yr total
+2342M
n=126 · 7 super · 33 busts · 72% pos surplus
Best pick Zack Martin · 2014 #16
#3
BALRavens
Hit %
16
Avg AV
10.5
Stars
22
Surplus $/yr
+5.2M
4-yr total
+2861M
n=137 · 4 super · 33 busts · 75% pos surplus
Best pick Lamar Jackson · 2018 #32
#4
ATLFalcons
Hit %
16
Avg AV
11.8
Stars
16
Surplus $/yr
+3.7M
4-yr total
+1523M
n=103 · 1 super · 26 busts · 74% pos surplus
Best pick Julio Jones · 2011 #6
#5
KANChiefs
Hit %
15
Avg AV
13.0
Stars
17
Surplus $/yr
+4.9M
4-yr total
+2139M
n=110 · 7 super · 32 busts · 70% pos surplus
Best pick Tyreek Hill · 2016 #165
#6
PHIEagles
Hit %
15
Avg AV
11.4
Stars
18
Surplus $/yr
+4.8M
4-yr total
+2265M
n=117 · 3 super · 34 busts · 68% pos surplus
Best pick Jason Kelce · 2011 #191
#7
MIADolphins
Hit %
14
Avg AV
9.4
Stars
15
Surplus $/yr
+3.6M
4-yr total
+1575M
n=109 · 2 super · 31 busts · 66% pos surplus
Best pick Minkah Fitzpatrick · 2018 #11
#8
LACChargers
Hit %
14
Avg AV
11.6
Stars
15
Surplus $/yr
+4.0M
4-yr total
+1722M
n=109 · 2 super · 29 busts · 70% pos surplus
Best pick Derwin James · 2018 #17
#9
HOUTexans
Hit %
13
Avg AV
10.2
Stars
15
Surplus $/yr
+4.2M
4-yr total
+1939M
n=116 · 3 super · 35 busts · 70% pos surplus
Best pick J.J. Watt · 2011 #11
#10
NORSaints
Hit %
13
Avg AV
11.8
Stars
12
Surplus $/yr
+3.7M
4-yr total
+1376M
n=93 · 3 super · 28 busts · 65% pos surplus
Best pick Cameron Jordan · 2011 #24
#11
MINVikings
Hit %
12
Avg AV
9.0
Stars
17
Surplus $/yr
+3.3M
4-yr total
+1893M
n=142 · 6 super · 49 busts · 64% pos surplus
Best pick Cordarrelle Patterson · 2013 #29
#12
JAXJaguars
Hit %
11
Avg AV
9.4
Stars
14
Surplus $/yr
+3.3M
4-yr total
+1601M
n=123 · 1 super · 31 busts · 69% pos surplus
Best pick Jalen Ramsey · 2016 #5
#13
TAMBuccaneers
Hit %
11
Avg AV
12.8
Stars
12
Surplus $/yr
+3.6M
4-yr total
+1542M
n=106 · 3 super · 23 busts · 75% pos surplus
Best pick Tristan Wirfs · 2020 #13
#14
BUFBills
Hit %
11
Avg AV
11.0
Stars
13
Surplus $/yr
+3.9M
4-yr total
+1812M
n=116 · 3 super · 28 busts · 74% pos surplus
Best pick Stephon Gilmore · 2012 #10
#15
PITSteelers
Hit %
11
Avg AV
10.9
Stars
13
Surplus $/yr
+3.8M
4-yr total
+1756M
n=116 · 5 super · 38 busts · 65% pos surplus
Best pick Cameron Heyward · 2011 #31
#16
LARRams
Hit %
11
Avg AV
10.1
Stars
15
Surplus $/yr
+4.1M
4-yr total
+2185M
n=134 · 6 super · 38 busts · 69% pos surplus
Best pick Aaron Donald · 2014 #13
#17
ARICardinals
Hit %
11
Avg AV
8.7
Stars
13
Surplus $/yr
+3.7M
4-yr total
+1739M
n=117 · 5 super · 34 busts · 67% pos surplus
Best pick Patrick Peterson · 2011 #5
#18
CARPanthers
Hit %
11
Avg AV
10.9
Stars
11
Surplus $/yr
+3.3M
4-yr total
+1351M
n=102 · 3 super · 30 busts · 67% pos surplus
Best pick Luke Kuechly · 2012 #9
#19
TENTitans
Hit %
11
Avg AV
9.8
Stars
12
Surplus $/yr
+3.0M
4-yr total
+1344M
n=113 · 4 super · 41 busts · 58% pos surplus
Best pick Kevin Byard · 2016 #64
#20
GNBPackers
Hit %
10
Avg AV
10.1
Stars
15
Surplus $/yr
+3.7M
4-yr total
+2098M
n=143 · 3 super · 44 busts · 68% pos surplus
Best pick Davante Adams · 2014 #53
#21
CHIBears
Hit %
10
Avg AV
10.2
Stars
11
Surplus $/yr
+3.5M
4-yr total
+1455M
n=105 · 1 super · 24 busts · 71% pos surplus
Best pick Roquan Smith · 2018 #8
#22
DENBroncos
Hit %
10
Avg AV
10.0
Stars
12
Surplus $/yr
+3.6M
4-yr total
+1704M
n=118 · 5 super · 35 busts · 69% pos surplus
Best pick Von Miller · 2011 #2
#23
NWEPatriots
Hit %
10
Avg AV
8.3
Stars
13
Surplus $/yr
+3.9M
4-yr total
+2091M
n=134 · 2 super · 38 busts · 70% pos surplus
Best pick Joe Thuney · 2016 #78
#24
NYJJets
Hit %
10
Avg AV
7.8
Stars
11
Surplus $/yr
+2.8M
4-yr total
+1289M
n=114 · 3 super · 43 busts · 57% pos surplus
Best pick Demario Davis · 2012 #77
#25
SEASeahawks
Hit %
9
Avg AV
10.6
Stars
13
Surplus $/yr
+3.8M
4-yr total
+2091M
n=137 · 5 super · 37 busts · 72% pos surplus
Best pick Bobby Wagner · 2012 #47
#26
WASCommanders
Hit %
9
Avg AV
9.4
Stars
12
Surplus $/yr
+3.3M
4-yr total
+1663M
n=128 · 0 super · 46 busts · 63% pos surplus
Best pick Brandon Scherff · 2015 #5
#27
NYGGiants
Hit %
9
Avg AV
8.9
Stars
10
Surplus $/yr
+2.6M
4-yr total
+1151M
n=110 · 1 super · 36 busts · 63% pos surplus
Best pick Saquon Barkley · 2018 #2
#28
CLEBrowns
Hit %
9
Avg AV
8.6
Stars
11
Surplus $/yr
+2.4M
4-yr total
+1223M
n=126 · 3 super · 51 busts · 56% pos surplus
Best pick Myles Garrett · 2017 #1
#29
SFO49ers
Hit %
8
Avg AV
8.9
Stars
11
Surplus $/yr
+3.8M
4-yr total
+2114M
n=138 · 4 super · 35 busts · 72% pos surplus
Best pick Fred Warner · 2018 #70
#30
CINBengals
Hit %
8
Avg AV
10.4
Stars
10
Surplus $/yr
+3.1M
4-yr total
+1626M
n=131 · 2 super · 38 busts · 69% pos surplus
Best pick Ja'Marr Chase · 2021 #5
#31
LVRRaiders
Hit %
6
Avg AV
7.6
Stars
8
Surplus $/yr
+2.8M
4-yr total
+1375M
n=124 · 1 super · 39 busts · 64% pos surplus
Best pick Khalil Mack · 2014 #5
#32
INDColts
Hit %
6
Avg AV
10.7
Stars
8
Surplus $/yr
+2.7M
4-yr total
+1362M
n=125 · 2 super · 39 busts · 68% pos surplus
Best pick Quenton Nelson · 2018 #6